Clear, Concise Communication Takes Time to Create
Edward Everett had every reason to feel ready for Gettysburg. He had served as governor of Massachusetts, president of Harvard, and secretary of state, and many considered him the finest speaker of his generation. He also had nearly two months to prepare.
On November 19, 1863, Everett spoke for about two hours to thousands of citizens and soldiers gathered to dedicate a cemetery for the Union dead. He covered how ancient Athens honored its war dead, how the war began, why secession was wrong, and how the three days of battle unfolded.
The speaker who followed him, Abraham Lincoln, had been asked for “a few appropriate remarks,” and took about two minutes. He gave the crowd one idea: the living could honor the dead by taking up “the unfinished work” they had fought for. The next day, Everett wrote to Lincoln, “I should be glad, if I could flatter myself that I came as near to the central idea of the occasion, in two hours, as you did in two minutes.”
Everett brought decades of skill to that platform, and he still recognized that Lincoln had reached the heart of the occasion more directly. Lincoln had prepared too. He received his invitation about two weeks before the ceremony and worked on his remarks across several drafts while running a war. His two minutes reflect how clearly he understood both what he needed to say and what that crowd needed to hear.
Most of us give presentations rather than orations, and the lesson carries over: concise communication takes time, because you often have to move back and forth between your message and your audience before either one comes into focus.
Good preparation takes time
People often show me something they’ve created and tell me how many hours it took. They’re proud of the result, but frustrated by the time it required. Then they ask how to work faster next time. Some parts of preparation do get faster with experience, but the part I find hardest to speed up is figuring out what will be most useful to the audience. Good writing and speaking still take me time, even after years of teaching both.
My students tend to learn the same lesson early in the semester. When I assign a presentation of a minute and a half to two minutes, many of them expect an easy assignment. Most discover that adding value in that little time requires more than an outline drafted the night before or just before class. They need time to decide what would add value for their audience, and then time to rehearse so they can deliver it within the limit.
French mathematician and philosopher Blaise Pascal described the same problem in 1656, near the end of one of his Provincial Letters: “I have made this one longer only because I have not had the leisure to make it shorter.” You may have felt the same thing when you had to cut a report to one page or a presentation to five minutes. Your first draft tends to come out long, and shortening it takes another round of work.
Concise and short are different goals, though. A concise message uses all the words your audience needs and no more, which means a concise proposal can still run several pages. A short message simply uses few words, and cutting too far can leave your audience with less than they need. Clarity deserves the priority, and conciseness serves it. Lincoln’s address happened to be both short and concise.
So why does a concise message take so long to create?
Clarity comes from moving between your message and your audience
Most of my preparation time moves back and forth between two questions: what do I need to say, and what does my audience need to hear? My answer to one tends to change my answer to the other. Thinking about the audience sometimes reveals that my original idea needs to change, not just how I explain it. I often start with a rough idea and a structure, and the better version tends to come after I work on it, step away, and come back.
The same cycle happens when I bring a proposal to colleagues. I usually start with an idea I believe in and a clear sense of why it would help. Then I think about each person who will hear it: what the change would ask of them, how it might affect their work, and what they would want to know first. Those questions often reshape the proposal itself, and the version I share tends to be clearer than the one I started with.
Lincoln's earliest surviving draft suggests that his two minutes were carefully prepared. The first page was written on Executive Mansion stationery, while the second was written on different paper, suggesting that he continued revising the address in Gettysburg. His secretary, John Nicolay, later recalled that Lincoln was still completing his preparations on the morning of the ceremony. The drafts show a writer who kept returning to his words.
Producing words is fast, and choosing what they should say takes time
You can fill a page in minutes, and generative AI can now draft one for you in seconds, with sentences that read smoothly. A smooth draft can still lack a central idea, though, and fluent sentences can make you feel finished before you’ve worked through what you need to say and what your audience needs to hear.
A long draft can hide that gap. You can circle an idea for pages without settling on it, and the growing page count can make you feel like you’re making progress. A concise version leaves less room to circle, so you have to decide how each sentence helps your audience understand your central idea.
The slow work is often deciding what to leave out. Some cuts are easy, but others involve facts, examples, and stories that are interesting yet do little to advance the central idea. The hardest are often the ones I've spent the most time developing. When I build a slide deck, I often drag a slide to the end and hide it before I'm ready to delete it. When I write, I save cut paragraphs at the bottom of the file. Sometimes I need distance from the draft before I can see that the message is stronger without them.
Experience speeds the mechanics more than the thinking
Experience has made some parts of my process faster. I can structure a presentation, tighten a sentence, or spot a weak transition more quickly than I could early in my career. Yet knowing a subject well isn’t the same as knowing what a particular audience needs from it. I could give a talk about writing effective emails tomorrow, but first-year students and executives would need different examples and takeaways. My familiarity with the topic saves preparation time; deciding how to make it useful to each audience still takes work.
Test whether you know your central idea
Before you start drafting, try stating your central idea in one sentence to someone who lacks your context. If they can repeat it back in their own words, you’re ready to structure the rest of the message around it. If you find yourself explaining for several minutes, you may need more thinking before more writing. The single sentence checks your message, and the listener checks whether it reaches someone else.
Reading aloud offers a second test. Once you can state your central idea, read your full draft aloud, whether it’s an email or a presentation. Hearing your own words tends to show you which points move your audience toward your central idea, which ones you can cut, and where your audience may need more.
Both tests take a few minutes, and they point your preparation time toward the back-and-forth between your message and your audience, where concise messages come from. If your last important message took longer than you hoped, those hours may have been the most valuable part of the work.
Before you prepare your next important message, ask yourself: What is the one thing my audience most needs to understand, remember, or do? If you can't answer that question in one sentence, you may need more thinking before more writing.
Sources
Everett, E. (1863, November 20). Letter to Abraham Lincoln. Abraham Lincoln Papers, Library of Congress. Transcription via House Divided, Dickinson College: https://hd.housedivided.dickinson.edu/node/42180
National Park Service. Lincoln and Gettysburg (Gettysburg National Military Park historical handbook), on the invitations: https://npshistory.com/handbooks/historical/9/hh9g1.htm
Library of Congress. First draft of the Gettysburg Address (Nicolay copy), on Executive Mansion stationery and the rewritten final page: https://webarchive.library.unt.edu/eot2008/20080925051209/http:/www.loc.gov/exhibits/treasures/trt034.html
American Battlefield Trust. Versions of the Gettysburg Address: https://www.battlefields.org/learn/articles/versions-gettysburg-address
Edward Everett biographical records (offices and dates), SNAC: https://snaccooperative.org/details/73844617/11245604
Pascal, B. (1656). Provincial Letters, Letter 16.


